Auto Accident Secrets
What insurers actually look at after a collision — and how to avoid costly mistakes.Auto Accident Secrets
If you’re involved in a car accident, what you do in the first few minutes can greatly affect how the insurance company evaluates your claim. This guide highlights the lesser-known factors insurers review, common mistakes drivers make, and how to protect yourself from unnecessary costs and delays.
What Insurance Companies Really Look For
- Accurate details about how the accident occurred.
- Photos of vehicle damage, surroundings, and road conditions.
- Timely reporting — delays can complicate or reduce coverage.
- Whether police were called and if a report was filed.
- Consistency between your statement and the other party’s version.
Steps to Take Immediately After an Accident
- Ensure everyone’s safety and call emergency services if needed.
- Take clear, wide-angle and close-up photos of damage and the scene.
- Exchange insurance and contact information with the other party.
- Do not admit fault — let the adjuster determine liability.
- Notify your insurance company as soon as possible.
How Jim Helps Clients After an Accident
As an independent broker, Jim is not the claim adjuster — but he helps you:
- Understand what’s covered and what isn’t.
- Report the claim correctly and avoid unnecessary delays.
- Communicate clearly with the carrier’s claims department.
- Review repair estimates and coverage questions.
- Decide whether a claim should even be filed in the first place.
Frequently Asked Questions
What To Do When Two Cars Back Up And Hit Each Other
When two vehicles are both backing up and collide, insurers often consider shared responsibility because both cars were in motion. Fault may not be assigned 50/50, but both drivers usually carry some level of responsibility. Document the scene thoroughly, take photos, and avoid admitting fault. Reporting the claim properly allows your broker to help reduce unnecessary surcharges and ensure the incident is classified correctly.
What To Do When You Hit A Moving Object
When you strike a moving object, insurance companies look at direction of travel, right of way, traffic violations, and reaction time. Even small details may shift liability between drivers. Multiple coverages may apply, including liability, collision, and medical payments. Gathering photos, witness information, and a clear description of events helps ensure the claim is evaluated fairly and positioned correctly by your broker.
What To Do When You Hit A Stationary Object
Accidents involving stationary objects are generally treated as at-fault collisions. Collision coverage applies, subject to your deductible. However, if the object belongs to someone else — such as a fence, garage door, sign, or parked car — liability coverage may also come into play. Prompt reporting avoids complications later, especially if injuries or hidden structural damage surface.
What To Do When You Are Backing Up And Hit A Car
In most states, the reversing driver is presumed responsible since vehicles in reverse must yield to all approaching traffic. But real-world circumstances matter: blocked visibility, illegally parked cars, shared backing situations, and multiple simultaneous maneuvers can all affect fault. Document what occurred, take clear photos, and call your broker early so the claim is presented accurately and prevents unnecessary premium impact.
What To Do When You Hit An Animal
Most people are surprised to learn that hitting an animal is normally considered a comprehensive claim, not collision. Comprehensive claims often avoid surcharges and use a different deductible. However, if you swerve to avoid the animal and hit another object, that becomes a collision claim. Proper classification makes a major difference in long-term insurance cost, so consult your broker before filing.
Legal Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only. Always check with your insurance agent, insurance company, or your state's Department of Insurance, as the information in this video for your state may be different.
Explore Jim’s Other Popular Insurance “Secrets” Videos
Select another topic below to continue learning the strategies Jim teaches Arizona families to avoid costly mistakes and protect themselves long before a claim ever happens.
- Auto Insurance Secrets– Deductibles, limits, rental reimbursement, towing, stacking, and how to protect yourself from uninsured and underinsured drivers.
- Home Insurance Secrets – How claims are scored, why coverage limits fail, how water losses are evaluated, and the #1 mistake homeowners make that costs them thousands.
- Umbrella, Collectibles & Life Secrets – How umbrella policies truly protect assets, how to insure valuables correctly, and common life-insurance traps to avoid.
- Claims Secrets (What Really Happens During a Claim) – What adjusters review behind the scenes, how claim files are scored, and which decisions can trigger denials or delays.
- Jim’s Favorite Secrets – The exact questions Jim hears from Arizona families — and the real guidance that has helped clients avoid denied claims and major financial losses.
- Insurance Company Customer & Claims Directory – A fast, always-updated reference with customer service numbers, claims hotlines, websites, and online payment portals.